Blog | Theology Project

Sep 20, 2018
2 min

When is a church not a church? | Mulholland on Revelation #UMC

…we see that orthodoxy and evangelism are the inseparable foci of a healthy church. Both must be kept in dynamic balance. Evangelism without orthodoxy becomes a tolerant pluralism and results in a community formed around diffuse human values and criteria. Orthodoxy without evangelism becomes a cold, harsh legalism and results in a community formed around debilitating “do’s and don’ts.” Sound orthodoxy and fervent evangelism result in a community of faith whose growing wholene

1 view0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Apr 1, 2015
1 min

Here’s My New Seven Minute Seminary: Resurrection and the Christian Afterlife (@OfficialSeedbe

Here’s the latest installment of Seedbed’s Seven Minute Seminary series in which I discuss several questions related to life after death, bodily resurrection, and the pastoral significance of the Christian hope. Watch to the end to discover why this doctrine is so very near and dear to my heart. Be sure also to check out this great little discussion guide that the Seedbed team has put together to accompany the video for use in a small group setting. Check out my other contrib

0 views0 comments

Jerry Walls Responds to my Question on Hell (@rachelheldevans)

Matt O'Reilly

Jul 31, 2013
4 min

Jerry Walls Responds to my Question on Hell (@rachelheldevans)

Jerry Walls is taking a turn in Rachel Held Evan’s “Ask a…” series, and he is answering question on hell, free will, and possibility of postmortem repentance. I raised a question about a surprising, if not disturbing, passage in Revelation that portrays the torment of hell as taking place eternally in the very presence of Christ. Here’s the passage from Revelation 14:9-11: Then another angel, a third, followed them, crying with a loud voice, “Those who worship the beast and i

0 views0 comments

Rough Magic: Paul and the Law in Narnian Perspective

Matt O'Reilly

Jun 26, 2013
4 min

Rough Magic: Paul and the Law in Narnian Perspective

Ever have the experience of reading a book only to have the author turn a phrase so well that it unexpectedly sheds new light on some matter on which you were not, at the moment, reflecting? That very thing happened to me not long ago while reading C.S. Lewis‘ The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. Let me say that I typically expect Lewis to push me to think about God, creation, redemption, and everything else in fresh ways. However, I wasn’t expecting him to hit me with a sentence

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Aug 27, 2012
3 min

Eternal Security? How do you fall away?

The starting point must be the comparison that Paul draws between God’s attitude toward unbelieving Israel and his audience in Rome. My previous suggestion that a believer can indeed fall to their peril is based on this comparison in which Paul tells the Roman Christians that Israel was broken off for unbelief; thus, his warning to the Romans, “if God did not spare the original branches, perhaps he will not spare you” (11:21). For the apostle, believing Gentile Christians are

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Aug 21, 2012
2 min

Eternal Security? My Crucial Verse

When it comes to the so-called doctrine of eternal security (or the perseverance of the saints), the crucial passage for me is Romans 11:17-24, especially verses 19-21. I formerly held the view that true believers cannot ultimately fall away, but my view was never exegetically grounded. It was motivated more by the psychological comfort of knowing I was indeed eternally secure. But the trouble with textually ungrounded psycho-therapeutic theological constructions is that they

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Jul 5, 2012
1 min

Why Read Revelation?

Revelation is not about the antichrist, but about the living Christ. It is not about a rapture out of this world but about faithful discipleship in this world. That is, like every other New Testament book, Revelation is about Jesus Christ – “A Revelation of Jesus Christ” (Rev 1:1) – and about following him in obdience and love. “If anyone asks, ‘Why read the Apocalypse?’, the unhesitating answer must be, ‘To know Christ better.'” It’s easy to lose sight of the reality that th

0 views0 comments

Comfort and Affliction: The Dual Message of Revelation

Matt O'Reilly

Jun 28, 2012
2 min

Comfort and Affliction: The Dual Message of Revelation

About seven years ago, when I began studing the Bible and Church history with significanly increased seriousness, I discovered not only that there were alternative approaches to reading Revelation, but that my default approach was a relatively recent historical development and that it was not firmly based on a careful reading of Revelation (or any part of scripture for that matter). But if Revelation isn’t about flying away to escape the horrors of the coming beast, then what

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Jun 21, 2012
2 min

Hell in the Presence of the Lamb?

“…they will drink the wine of God’s wrath, poured unmixed into the cup of his anger, and they will be tormented with fire and sulfur in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb. And the smoke of their torment goes up forever and ever” (14:10). What? Did you catch that? They will be tormented forever in the presence of the Lamb? John seems to be suggesting that those who oppose Jesus in the present life by worshipping the beast (14:9) exist forever in so

1 view0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Feb 7, 2012
2 min

An Eschatology of Hope

We have seen that, when read in light of Jewish apocalyptic literature, the disappearance of the sea in Rev 21:1 paints a symbolic picture of a day to be longed for, a day when God will remove from the created order all that is evil and antithetical to his purposes and to his people, a day when creation will emerge from its sorrow into the bliss of God’s manifest presence. This is a day of hope, and in the Apocalypse of John, it is that day for which the faithful around the t

0 views0 comments

Theory or History? The Difference is Important

Matt O'Reilly

Oct 24, 2011
2 min

Theory or History? The Difference is Important

It’s one thing for this to be the language of professional academic guilds, but I hope this language doesn’t work it’s way into the Church. Why? Well, I’m glad you asked. It’s important because atonement and justification have to do with how we come into a right relationship with God. And from a pastoral perspective, I don’t want to leave that up to theory. Paul wrote of sinners that, “they are now justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jes

0 views0 comments

For the Poor and the Alien: An Evangelical-Wesleyan Approach to Immigration

Matt O'Reilly

Sep 29, 2011
3 min

For the Poor and the Alien: An Evangelical-Wesleyan Approach to Immigration

Let me begin by saying that the following reflections arise out of my evangelical and Wesleyan commitments. I say that up front because it often seems to me that those who identify themselves as evangelical tend to favor strict immigration laws. I will contend, though, that an evangelical approach calls us to remember that God has welcomed us when we were not only strangers but enemies. When I combine this with my Wesleyan commitment that the people of God are to reflect the

0 views0 comments

A Wet Dedication? One More Thought on the Baptism Debate

Matt O'Reilly

Aug 22, 2011
3 min

A Wet Dedication? One More Thought on the Baptism Debate

I’ve been interacting with Mike Bird’s recent posts (1, 2) on dual baptism in which he calls paedobaptists and credobaptists to peace and unity. I really appreciate what he has to say on the matter and wish very much that this wasn’t the big deal debate that it is. In my last post, I suggested that the difference between paedos and credos might be beyond reconciliation in that the views contain fundamental theological contradictions. In this post, I want to consider one impli

0 views0 comments

The Baptism Debate: Is there a middle way?

Matt O'Reilly

Aug 19, 2011
2 min

The Baptism Debate: Is there a middle way?

New Testament scholar Mike Bird has written two thought-provoking posts with precisely this aim of finding a middle way (part 1, part 2). Bird helpfully points out that both credo and paedo baptism have roots in early Christian history, and that both have something to teach us. He also reminds us that it is very difficult to get a very clear picture of how children of believers were regarded when it came to baptism in the New Testament period. I particularly appreciate his l

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Apr 27, 2011
1 min

Eschatology is Everything

Consider, for Paul that justification is the present faith-anticipation of the eschatological verdict. Sanctification is the Spirit-life of the future come into the present. Salvation itself is a matter of being united with Christ in his death and resurrection, which is the first fruits of the final resurrection of the people of God. The presence of the Spirit in the Church marks it out as an eschatological community. And the Mosaic Law, though it was a good thing, is now obs

0 views0 comments

Methodists and the Meaning of Membership

Matt O'Reilly

Dec 16, 2010
1 min

Methodists and the Meaning of Membership

I was pleasantly surprised to see Bishop Will Willimon’s recent blog post on the importance of “Making Membership Mean Something.” I was excited because I have begun to think recently that the meaning of membership may be the issue facing United Methodists now and in the coming years. Many of our denominational battles revolve around the meaning of membership; indeed, some have tried through various means to make membership absolutely meaningless. In recent years these at

0 views0 comments

What About Imputation? More on N.T. Wright at ETS

Matt O'Reilly

Dec 9, 2010
2 min

What About Imputation? More on N.T. Wright at ETS

In a recent post, I said that N.T. Wright’s presentation at ETS surprised me with regard to two areas: his clarification regarding final justification and the role of works and his comments on imputation. Here are my reflections on the role of works. Now on to the matter of imputation. Wright has often suggested that the Reformed doctrine of imputation makes righteousness out to be a gas-like substance that can be passed across the divine courtroom from judge to defendant.

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Dec 4, 2010
3 min

Belated ETS & SBL Reflections

I’m a bit behind most in the blogosphere who have already posted reflections on the recent annual gatherings of the Evangelical Theological Society and the Society of Biblical Literature in Atlanta. Nonetheless, here are a few thoughts: 1. This was the first year I attended ETS. I was struck by the charity and reverence throughout. You might be surprised to hear that I was struck in this way, ETS being a confessional professional society composed of people who are supposed

0 views0 comments

Can We Speak of the Righteousness of Christ?

Matt O'Reilly

Jun 21, 2010
3 min

Can We Speak of the Righteousness of Christ?

In recent debates over the Reformation doctrine of Justification, the phrase “the righteousness of Christ” has come under heavy criticism. The doctrine of Justification asserts that a person is justified, or declared righteous, before God only because the righteousness of Christ has been imputed or reckoned to that person through faith in Christ. The controversy comes because the specific Greek phrase dikaiosunē Christou (the righteousness of Christ) does not appear in the

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly

Apr 24, 2010
3 min

Reading Mark: An Interpretive Key

I’ve been preaching through the Gospel of Mark for nearly seven months now, and I am repeatedly considering questions regarding the appropriate way to read and interpret the narrative. I’ve been considering this question with particular interest in interpreting the signs (or miracles) of Jesus. The miracle texts are often simply taken as affirmations of Jesus’ divine nature, and while that may be involved, I’m not so sure that’s what Mark is really getting at with the mirac

0 views0 comments

Matt O'Reilly, PhD

Pastor | Author | Public Theologian

When is a church not a church? | Mulholland on Revelation #UMC

Here’s My New Seven Minute Seminary: Resurrection and the Christian Afterlife (@OfficialSeedbe

Jerry Walls Responds to my Question on Hell (@rachelheldevans)

Rough Magic: Paul and the Law in Narnian Perspective

Eternal Security? How do you fall away?

Eternal Security? My Crucial Verse

Why Read Revelation?

Comfort and Affliction: The Dual Message of Revelation

Hell in the Presence of the Lamb?

An Eschatology of Hope

Theory or History? The Difference is Important

For the Poor and the Alien: An Evangelical-Wesleyan Approach to Immigration

A Wet Dedication? One More Thought on the Baptism Debate

The Baptism Debate: Is there a middle way?

Eschatology is Everything

Methodists and the Meaning of Membership

What About Imputation? More on N.T. Wright at ETS

Belated ETS & SBL Reflections

Can We Speak of the Righteousness of Christ?

Reading Mark: An Interpretive Key